Tomball Councilman Explains Rejection Of Immigration-Related Laws

The Tomball City Council has rejected two ordinances aimed at illegal immigration. A councilman who voted against the measures last night says one of the laws wouldn't have solved a real problem, while the other would have resulted in legal challenges the city can't afford. David Pitman has more.

One of the proposed laws would have made English the official language of Tomball.  It failed on a vote of three to one.  Preston Dodson is one of the councilmembers who voted no.    He says the English-only measure was purely symbolic.

"Without having some purpose for the ordinance, some way it's going to advance and enhance the city of Tomball, we don't need it."

The second ordinance the council voted down would have barred illegal immigrants from renting or owning property or operating a business inside city limits.  Councilman Dodson says Tomball is heeding the lesson learned by a Dallas suburb that approved a similar law, which a judge later found to be unconstitutional.

"Farmers Branch, we understand, has spent three-and-a-half, four million dollars defending their ordinance.  We can't do that.  These ordinances have failed in every venue."

Dodson says a third measure, one that would require city contractors and their subcontractors to hire only legal immigrant labor will be adopted at a later meeting as policy for contracts, rather than voted in as law. 

Bio photo of David Pitman

David Pitman

Local Host, Morning Edition

The one question David hears most often isn't "What is it like to work for an NPR member station?" or "Have you ever met Terry Gross?" (he has)...